Mapping the Unmappable
Question 1: How can we convey historical, affective, and sensory experiences of the city in visible form on a map? In what ways could we move beyond the top-down, god’s-eye view privileged by city-planners and politicians, and instead represent the richer messier, more human experience on the ground? What kinds of aesthetic tools can we use to go beyond the illusory reality of photography, to capture a more ‘suggestive’ representation of experience?

Question 2: Can resisting ‘legible’ behavior become a set of urban tactics? In his classic 1960 text, The Image of the City, Kevin Lynch developed a schematic classification of urban elements that make a city legible. He also implied that legibility is synonymous with a ‘pleasing’ aesthetic atmosphere. The drive for legibility and its normative aesthetic vision rely on the exclusion of elements that disturb the planner’s sense of balance, for instance ‘ethnic’ or ‘class’ neighborhoods in Lynch’s case. The construction of a desired atmosphere implicitly requires the control of both the aesthetics of the built environment and the aesthetics of the residents’ behavior. Behavior that is disturbing – in every sense of the term – is deemed illegible. What seems illegible to the dominant strata is legible to those ‘below’ and on the margins, however, as they inhabit these spaces and behaviors. Rather than illegible, such spaces and behaviors are anti-legible as part of the inhabitants’ mazeway. Can acts of anti-legibility be regarded as creative forms of endurance and persistence? How can we avoid romanticizing anti-legibility as overt resistance, raising the danger of ignoring the conditions of structural domination that create the necessity for survival strategies in the first place?

Question 3: What are the urban arts, beyond the formal institutions of the culture industry? What types of activities would we include in that concept? We aim, here, to look beyond official, overtly funded artistic initiatives, which are often a tool used for gentrification. Instead we are looking for more spontaneous, organic forms of creative expression. In the former, the culture industry places its mark on the urban space in the construction of arts venues to draw suburbanites into the city. While such programs foster the arts, they also reconfigure art-consumerism as an engine of economic growth. The commodification of creative expression overlooks the many ways in which city residents create their own aesthetic experiences, as well as the social communities that bind these experiences together. The organic urban arts focus more on local, spontaneous, and social forms of creative expression, such as the narrative practices of street-corner culture, sidewalk boom box parties, the rhythms and choreography of people moving down city streets, and embodied social performance in dance clubs, movie theaters, parks, train stations, and other venues of sociability.
